Elementum
← Back to brand, awareness and storytelling

The Brand, Awareness and Storytelling Diagnostic.

You know your communication is not working, but you do not yet know where the break is, and the break decides the work.

Communication trouble comes in four shapes that need completely different fixes: your message is muddled so people cannot say what you do, you have no compelling case so asks fall flat, you never tell your impact or tell it badly, or you are simply invisible and unheard. This guide sorts out which one you have, confirms it is really about your public communication, tests how outsiders actually receive you against how you assume they do, and hands you a plan. It is a sorting instrument, not a fix. It will not write your message or your case; it tells you which kind of trouble you have and in what order to work it. It takes about ninety minutes, and it asks for the humility to find out how outsiders actually see you rather than how you hope they do.

Step 1

Picture your current communication and how you are seen

You cannot diagnose communication you have not laid out: what you say, where you say it, and how the outside world actually receives it. Gather how you currently describe yourself, your website, your materials, your social presence, your last appeal, and note where each says something different. Then write down the honest signs of how you are received: do people know you exist, can they say what you do, do your asks land.

Who: you, or your communications or development lead, with anyone who handles your outward communication. Produces: a clear picture of what you say, where you say it, and how the outside world actually receives it, with the inconsistencies flagged. This is your Communication Snapshot.

Open the Communication Snapshot →
Step 2

Confirm it is a public-communication problem, and locate the break

First, make sure you are in the right place. Then place your trouble in one of the four shapes, because the shape decides the guide.

Produces: a single, named finding, confirmed to be a public-communication problem: your trouble lives in clarity, case, story, or awareness. This scored read is the Communication Diagnostic.

Step 3

Test how outsiders actually receive you, and tell misunderstood from unknown

Leaders are too close to their own message to judge whether it lands, so a rating you give yourself is worth little until an outsider tests it. And two problems look identical from the inside but need opposite fixes: being misunderstood, where people have heard of you but do not get it, and being unknown, where they have never heard of you at all. Ask three or four people outside your organization, separately, what they think you do and why it matters, and compare their answers to what you believe you say. Where the honest answer is worse than you expected, trust the honest answer.

Who: you, plus a few outsiders who will answer honestly, a lapsed donor, a community member, someone who should know you but may not. Produces: an honest read of how outsiders actually receive you, and whether your deeper problem is being misunderstood or being unknown, which fixes are opposite. This is your Outside-In Reality Check.

Open the Outside-In Reality Check →
Step 4

Prioritize and sequence into your plan

Turn the finding into an ordered plan that names your first guide and follows the order communication is actually built: clarify the message, make the case, tell the story, get seen. Where you have more than one, build in that order. You cannot make a case or tell a story from a muddled message, and getting seen with a message that does not land just spreads the confusion faster. Add anything the front-gate surfaced, the mission work if the deeper problem is mission, the impact work if your case needs evidence you do not have. Give the first guide a real start date, and fix the single most visible failure, the confusing website line, the elevator answer, this week.

Who: you, with comms or development staff, and a board member who will need to carry the message. Produces: the prioritized action plan. You leave this guide knowing exactly which guide is yours, what follows it, and when you start. This is your Prioritized Communication Plan.

Open the Prioritized Communication Plan →

Your answers stay in your browser on this page and are never sent anywhere. Use Save or print to keep your copy.

The honest edge

Two moments here reach past these pages. If you find you genuinely cannot afford the time or skill to produce polished materials once your message is clear, a designer or a communications professional is legitimate help for the specialized production, and this work will point you there when you reach it, while keeping the thinking yours. And if testing how you are seen surfaces that people distrust you because of something real, a past harm, a broken promise, no message fixes that; the repair is real accountability, not better words. Naming these is not the guide failing. It is the guide being honest about its edge.

If you arrived here in a crisis and have now steadied

Once your communication is clearer, it is worth stepping back to look at the whole organization, not just how it is seen. There is a short whole-organization check-up waiting for you when you are ready. That is not a sales pitch. It is the next honest thing to look at. The whole-organization check-up →

You can always go back to the overview or start over from the welcome page.