Prepare and make the in-person ask, because the most common reason organizations do not receive major gifts is that no one ever directly asked.
Reconnect and thank them first. Make the case briefly. Ask for the specific amount, out loud. Then stop talking and let them respond. The silence after the ask is theirs, not yours to fill.
A yes gets a thank-you and stewardship. A not now gets gratitude and a preserved relationship, because today's no is often tomorrow's yes if you do not sour it.
Your answers stay in your browser on this page and are never sent anywhere. Use Save or print to keep your copy.